Now that the madness has subsided from this year’s BSM Top 20, I thought I’d weigh in with a few final thoughts and takeaways from this year’s process. Overall it was a huge success again. I want to thank everyone who stopped by to see the results, share it on social media, and participate in the voting process.
One thing I’ve learned from running point on this process the past two years is that it’s extremely subjective and will never please everyone. That said, there are many in the radio industry who appreciate the recognition, and positive acknowledgement for a job well done never looks bad to a station’s audience or advertisers.
I also think it’s important for industry members to contribute to the voting process since they see the inner workings and the truth behind the numbers more than anyone else. Will they be biased at times? Of course. But I’d rather have executives with a favorable view of their brands contributing rather than relying on people who are outside the business and lack the information and personal insight to know whether or not a show, station or individual is experiencing success.
If you didn’t read the articles and fast forwarded to the results, I want to reiterate one key part that I often worry might be misconstrued. I do NOT vote in this process. I simply present the industry’s findings. I have opinions just like anyone else, and one of the toughest parts of this project is seeing particular votes come in that I disagree with, yet knowing that my role is to remain true to the votes and let the panel present their collective opinions without interference.
I recognize that a few observers and readers know that I work with some stations, and have friendships all across the nation. I can’t tell each individual what to think, but one thing I will not do with this annual representation of the format is have the final results determined by personal preference or economic influence.
I started this project and turned to executives at more than fifteen media companies to get involved because I heard from a large number of folks that they were frustrated by having the success of their brands and people determined by outlets which made their ranking decisions based on relationships and advertising buys. They also didn’t include industry members in the voting process. After doing this for two years, I can proudly say that I have not accepted a dime for it. I could easily do that and treat my family to a few more vacations and expensive dinners, but my credibility and respect for this business will not allow money to influence how I treat this process.
Trust me, it isn’t easy when you’re in my shoes presenting these findings, and a client I work with, finishes behind a competitor. It can be challenging and frustrating and puts me in an awkward spot. I could easily twist the results to favor my clients, but then I have to ask myself “why am I even doing this project if I’m not going to treat the votes of the industry panel with the respect it deserves”?
Last week for example during the process, I had one particular station take aim at me because they felt I was lifting up the profile of a competitor. Rather than giving credit where it was due to a station which was the top spoken word brand in the market, and ranked 3rd overall with a 9 share, and instead of conducting a self analysis given that their own performance was below a 1 share, the easy excuse was to blame yours truly.
If it helps a station’s staff sleep better at night to create excuses then that’s fine by me. The bottom line, industry people know which brands win and which ones don’t, and if you want to gain a stronger reputation and earn a higher place on the chart, you’re going to have to back it up with evidence that shows your performance is among the best. If not, it’ll be a similar story next year. I don’t play favorites, I just present the information.
Aside from that senseless drama, there were some results I agreed and disagreed with but that’s the beauty of life in America in 2017. You can have an opinion and choose to ignore anything you wish. I felt better about this year’s panel given the addition of a few more folks in smaller regions, which was especially helpful in determining the mid-market categories. I put a lot of time and thought into the voting process and aim to include people from all companies so it doesn’t become a one group celebration. It’s not perfect, but it’s as fair and balanced as it can be.
As far as this year’s results are concerned, I do have a few takeaways I want to share. These were things that stood out to me during the process. If you have some you’d like to discuss, you can always email me at JBarrett@hvy.tcp.mybluehost.me.
- The decision to split up the Major and Mid Markets felt right, and I’m glad we did it. Too often smaller regions get ignored and stand little chance of making noise against brands with outstanding heritage. This year they were able to get a better sense of how they’re viewed, and the major market shows received votes without the voters feeling obliged to ignore 1 or 2 of them just to make sure they offered some recognition to smaller market brands.
- Boomer and Carton, Mike Francesa, and Colin Cowherd were repeat winners, and reaffirmed that they’ve become the local and national shows which executives compare all others to. Next year will be very different if Mike Francesa fulfills his promise to leave WFAN, but for now, all three of these shows are a huge hit with high ranking members of the industry.
- FOX Sports Radio has done a magnificent job of rebuilding its image. After Jim Rome left for CBS, there was a period of time where industry folks I spoke to weren’t convinced the network was trending upward. Over the past two years though that perception has been changed. FSR had 6 shows in the Top 20 including 3 in the Top 10, signaling that they’re on their way to a strong resurgence.
- ESPN Radio remains in strong shape but if the rumors of a Mike and Mike split hold true, it could be an interesting time for the network. As great as the brand is and has been, they’re vulnerable for the first time in a long time. That said, no company has done a better job over the past three decades of replacing top talent and maintaining its relationships and stellar image than ESPN. It was interesting to see Paul Finebaum continue to gain momentum with voters. Bomani Jones also increased year to year and is now viewed slightly higher than Russillo and Kanell. ESPN has an opportunity to breathe some new life into its brand if it chooses to do so. If it stands pat with Mike and Mike, that too has large upside. This will be an interesting story to follow in 2017.
- Voters are very aware of what’s been taking place in Boston and rewarded both 98.5 The Sports Hub and WEEI for their performances. Without question, Boston is the hottest rated sports radio market in the country, and the competition between the two brands is as intense as ever. To see each station earn respect for the contributions they’re making to the format was a welcomed sight.
- The same story was true for 104.5 The Zone in Nashville, 93.7 The Fan in Pittsburgh and 101 ESPN in St. Louis. All three stations ranked high with our panel in the mid-market categories which speaks to each of their abilities to penetrate their markets and create a dominant presence with local sports radio enthusiasts.
- If there’s an area I’d like to see improve from the voters it’s to reward more shows for the current year’s actual performance instead of its reputation. I can’t speak for each voter but the goal is to recognize those who performed best during the previous calendar year. It’s no different than MLB or the NFL picking an MVP who had the best season. In some instances I see brands and shows receive high voting placement based on market size, brand reputation or length of service, and I think we collectively can do a better job of familiarizing ourselves with those who have performed best.
- That last section is important for on-air talent to remember. There were a few hosts who reached out to express displeasure about not being on the list or eligible for consideration, but as I stated numerous times, this wasn’t a sports radio draft, and it wasn’t a case of who’d get hired if executives had to make a business decision for their brands. This was simply about 2016’s performance. You can’t be mentioned as one of the best 25-35 shows during the year if you only spent 3-4 months on the air. For example, Gary Sanchez had a hot summer for the NY Yankees, but he wasn’t part of the MVP conversation, nor did he deserve to be. Same rules apply here.
- There were a few situations where key talent were gone for extended periods of time yet that didn’t hurt them in the voting which surprised me. Case in point, Terry Boers and Terry Foster missed time on the air in Detroit and Chicago, and the same was true for Greg Papa in San Francisco. Each of those hosts and shows deserve to be featured high but one can make a case that they deserve to go down a notch or two if they’re not at full strength for a significant period of time, especially if another show/brand behind them performed in similar fashion.
- In the mid-markets I was pleasantly surprised to see Bernie Miklasz, Dan Dakich and 3HL get recognized for their exceptional work. I’m familiar with all three shows and think they do an outstanding job and I felt the panel got each of those decisions right. There were a few other shows in their respective categories that I could also make a case for but you won’t get an argument from me when it comes to acknowledging those programs for doing an outstanding job.
- In the major-markets, I was happy to see G-Bag Nation and Paul Allen earn some recognition for what they bring to the airwaves. Both shows are very good and rate well. I also felt Mike Missanelli was rewarded for having an incredible year in Philadelphia, and the same was true for The Musers in Dallas, and OMF in Boston. Each deserved to be in the top 3 and you can make a case that they could’ve been ranked higher. I also thought Chris Mannix and the Morning Men sneaking into the National section was a pleasant surprise.
- A few programs were rated lower than I expected. Among them were the Michael Kay Show, Kap and Company, and Dan Barreiro. All three have generated better performance than where they were placed, but if they continue their momentum I suspect they’ll climb the ladder next year. When we conduct this process again next year I also won’t be surprised if Clay Travis, Dale and Holley with Rich Keefe, and Stephen A. Smith gain ground as all three are positioned to make a bigger splash.
- I’ll be interested to see how a couple of changes in January factor into next year’s results. Jay Mohr is gone from FOX Sports Radio, Danny Parkins has left 610 Sports in KC for 670 The Score in Chicago, Terry Boers’ retirement opened the door for Jason Goff to move into afternoons with Dan Bernstein, and a few other brands have made tweaks too. How they’re received by next year’s panel will be an interesting follow.
- Last but not least, Sports Radio WIP will have a full year under their belts with their new midday and afternoon shows which should put them back in the mix. Josh Innes will have developed a longer body of work in Houston putting him back on the radar. And Jorge Sedano, Keyshawn Johnson, and LZ Granderson will be up for consideration if they continue hosting mornings in Los Angeles and producing results. Where each of those shows finish is anyone’s guess, but clearly there’s a lot of talent there and the voters will have some difficult decisions to make.
To bring this to a close, it’s a fun exercise, and it allows many in our format to gain a sense of where they’re seen by high ranking industry officials. If you’re ranked high, you clearly are going to enjoy it and let the whole world know. You may even try to use it to your economic benefit with advertisers. If you’re not, you’ll likely find fault with the system and let everyone know that industry executives are asleep at the wheel.
It may not be perfect but it’s the best we can do. So until next time, thanks for reading, voting, sharing, and debating. Now keep those ratings and revenues high so we can explore this conversation again in 2018.
John Skipper To Speak At The 2022 BSM Summit
“In January 2021, Skipper’s plate became even more full when he reunited with Dan Le Batard to create Meadowlark Media. Since joining forces, the group has raised millions of dollars in funding, lured key talent to join the brand, and in April, Meadowlark closed a deal with DraftKings for a reported fifty million dollars over three years. Not too shabby for year #1.
Putting on a two-day industry conference comes with a fair share of challenges. Months are spent building sessions, selling sponsorships, and talking to so many people that by the time the event rolls around, all I can think about is reaching the finish line and avoiding major issues.
But then the event happens, and there are moments where I’m able to block out the noise for 30-40 minutes and just be present in conversation. It’s what I enjoy most. Being able to sit across from an industry leader who’s been successful in business, and pick their brain on the past, present and future of our industry is both personally and professionally fulfilling. Not only does it provide me with an education, but it helps everyone in attendance too. That’s my motivation for running this conference.
When we return to New York City on March 2-3, 2022, I’m thrilled to share that I’ll have a chance to do that once again with someone I’ve professionally respected and admired for a long time. It is an honor to announce that Meadowlark Media CEO John Skipper will join us for a special on stage conversation at the 2022 BSM Summit.
If you’ve worked in this industry or aspire to, then you’re likely aware of what John has accomplished. He’s seen the business from many different points of view and remains very much involved in helping shape its future. But before we discuss his present involvement, let’s revisit the past.
During his tenure with ESPN, John spent five years serving as company president where he secured a series of long-term, multiplatform agreements with key rightsholders such as the NBA, NFL, MLB, Major College Conferences, US Open Tennis, FIFA, the Masters Tournament and British Open, the College Football Playoff, and the Rose, Sugar and Orange Bowls. He also oversaw the evolution of several brands including The Undefeated, Grantland, five thirty eight, and espnW among others.
Prior to becoming company president, John held the position as EVP of Content, which he earned after helping create and introduce one of the most successful magazine launches of the 1990’s with ESPN The Magazine. His understanding and belief in digital helped ESPN move ESPN. com forward in 2000, adding a paid section, ESPN Insider, and delivering a revamped site approach to generate more advertising. His foresight also spurred the launch of ESPN3, a television network producing more than 4,000 live events on the web and through mobile devices. If that wasn’t enough, John also supported the creation of the Watch ESPN app, played a key role in elevating the careers of many of the industry’s top sports media stars today, and oversaw the growth of ESPN Films, ESPN Radio, and many of ESPN’s key television programs.
After exiting the worldwide leader, John signed on as the Executive Chairman of DAZN. In January 2021, Skipper’s plate became even more full when he reunited with Dan Le Batard to create Meadowlark Media. Since joining forces, the group has raised millions of dollars in funding, lured a number of key talent to become part of the brand, and established a strong presence in podcasting and on YouTube. In April, Meadowlark closed a deal with DraftKings for a reported fifty million dollars over three years. Not too shabby for year #1.
What I’ve appreciated about John is that he’s never been afraid to roll the dice and take risks. Some of his moves have worked out, others haven’t. The wins have been recognized across the industry, but so too have the losses. He’s had to lead a company thru high profile talent controversies, cord cutting challenges, understand the world of video, audio, print, digital, advertising, subscriptions, talent, and rights deals both domestic and internationally, all while keeping his finger on the pulse of the present state of the media business while turning an eye towards the future and knowing which areas the company should make significant investments in.
John has been thru all of it as a media executive, and he’s still doing it while building the Meadowlark brand. A recent story in Bloomberg captured some of his views on growing the Le Batard empire and navigating various parts of the industry. I highly recommend taking time to read it. You can do that by clicking here.
We have five and a half months until we’re inside the Anne Bernstein Theater in New York City, so who knows where the industry will shift during that time. One thing is for certain, John Skipper will be ready for whatever lands on his doorstep. I’m eager to spend time with him in New York treating industry professionals to his insights, opinions and leadership lessons. I’m confident those in attendance will gain value from hearing his perspectives on the industry.
I invite you to join us either in person or virtually for the 2022 BSM Summit. Tickets to the event can be purchased by clicking here. For information on sponsorship opportunities, email JBarrett@sportsradiopd.com.
2022 BSM Summit Adds Pablo Torre, Joe Fortenbaugh, Kazeem Famuyide & John Jastremski
“By the time March’s conference rolls around, we’ll have somewhere between 50-60 people announced to participate at the two day Summit.”
The announcements continue for the 2022 BSM Summit. After recently sharing the news that former ESPN Radio executive Traug Keller would join us in the big apple to accept the Jeff Smulyan Award, and previously revealing the first fourteen participants scheduled to appear, it’s time to inform you of a few key talent who will participate in sessions at March’s show.
I’m thrilled to welcome ESPN’s Pablo Torre to the 2022 BSM Summit. Pablo’s been with the worldwide leader since 2012. During that time he’s served as a senior writer for ESPN.com, the host of the ESPN Daily podcast, and has appeared on shows such as Around The Horn, Highly Questionable, and The Dan Le Batard Show. He also previously co-hosted High Noon with Bomani Jones. Prior to joining ESPN he spent five years writing for Sports Illustrated. Having worked with a mixture of talent from various backgrounds, I’m looking forward to having him share his insight and opinions on the value of it at the show.
Pablo isn’t the only ESPN personality joining us in New York for the conference. I’m excited to welcome back a great friend and one of the smartest sports betting analysts on television, Joe Fortenbaugh. Joe is regularly featured on ESPN’s sports betting program Daily Wager. He also appears on other ESPN programs and segments on television, radio and digital platforms. Prior to joining the network he hosted 95.7 The Game’s morning show in San Francisco, and hosted “The Sharp 600″ sports betting podcast. He’ll moderate a conversation with sports betting executives at the show.
Given that this two-day sports media conference is taking place in the heart of New York City, it’d be silly to not include someone who’s passion, energy, sound, and content embody what New York is all about. The Ringer’s John Jastremski will make his BSM Summit debut in 2022. The ‘New York, New York’ host is known to many for his years of contributions on WFAN. It’ll be fun picking JJ’s brain on the differences between performing on a traditional platform and the digital stage.
Jastremski isn’t the only one with a connection to The Ringer who will participate at our 2022 event. My next guest is someone who I’ve followed on YouTube and Twitter for years, has infectious energy and likeability, and has taken his life experiences and sports passions and turned them into opportunities with MSG Network, SNY, The Ringer, Bleacher Report, WWE, The Source and various other outlets. Kazeem Famuyide will join us to shed light on his journey and offer his perspective on the value of traditional vs. non-traditional paths.
By the time March’s conference rolls around, we’ll have somewhere between 50-60 people announced to participate at the two day event. I’ll be announcing the addition of a very special executive in mid-October, as well as a few high profile speakers and awards recipients in the weeks and months ahead. I’m appreciative of so many expressing interest in speaking at the conference, and as much as I’d like to include everyone on stage, I can’t. Keeping the Summit informative, fresh and focused on the right issues is important, and to do that, I’ve got to introduce different people, perspectives and subjects so our attendees gain value to further improve the industry.
A reminder, the 2022 BSM Summit is strictly for members of the sports media industry and college students aspiring to work in the business. It brings together people from more than thirty different media companies and focuses on issues of relevance and importance to media industry professionals. The show takes place March 2-3, 2022 in New York at the Anne Bernstein Theater on West 50th Street. Tickets and hotel rooms can be secured by visiting BSMSummit.com. For those unable to attend in person, the Summit will also be available to view online. Virtual tickets can be purchased by clicking here. Hope you’ll join us!
Traug Keller Named 2022 Recipient of the Jeff Smulyan Award
“Former SVP of ESPN Audio and President of ABC Networks Traug Keller has been chosen as our 2022 recipient of the Jeff Smulyan Award.”
Sometimes decisions are difficult. Other times they’re not. This was one of the easiest ones I’ve made since launching the BSM Summit in 2018.
If you haven’t attended the Summit before, one of the cool parts of the conference each year is that we take time to honor people who have left a permanent mark on the industry we love. Awards ceremonies are held both days to recognize difference makers who have made positive contributions to the sports radio business. At our 2022 BSM Summit, I am pleased to share that a great man will be celebrated for his life’s work.
It is my honor to announce that former SVP of ESPN Audio and President of ABC Networks Traug Keller has been chosen as our 2022 recipient of the Jeff Smulyan Award. Keller becomes the third industry executive to earn the honor. Kraig Kitchin and Dan Mason were the first two to be recognized at the 2019 and 2020 BSM Summit’s.
Upon learning that Traug had been selected as the next Jeff Smulyan Award winner, Emmis Communications CEO Jeff Smulyan said, “Traug Keller has left an indelible imprint on not only sports radio, but on all of broadcasting through his remarkable career. I’m proud to call him my friend, but I’m just one of the legions of people who have loved every minute of their time with him. He’s a broadcaster’s broadcaster, but more than that he’s one of the best people I’ve ever known.”
“I am humbled for sure but thrilled to be receiving an award with the name of my good friend on it, Jeff Smulyan,” added Traug Keller, now the EVP and COO of American Media. “Jeff did what all too few leaders in business do, he took risk and action against all kinds of headwinds and the rest of us in the great business of Sports Audio were the beneficiaries of it. Thanks to BSM for this great honor and I look forward to seeing a bunch of old friends in March!”
Anyone who has crossed paths with Traug over the past three decades knows how important he was to the success of ESPN Radio. He’s been a friend to many, a great partner to hundreds of radio affiliates, and a champion for talent. His support for BSM has also meant a lot.
Perhaps even more impressive was Traug’s ability to connect with his affiliates, clients and colleagues, offering steady leadership and on-air stability for ESPN Radio. No executive leaves with a perfect record, but Keller had a knack for landing on the right side of many decisions. None as impressive though as retiring from sports radio in February 2020, one month before the sports world came to a screeching halt and a global pandemic rocked the entire advertising industry. Talk about timing Traug, haha.
In all seriousness, having Traug and Jeff together on the same stage in front of the industry to give folks an opportunity to show their appreciation for their accomplishments is a real treat. So many enjoy professional success today due to bold and smart decisions made by each of these men, and I couldn’t be happier to spend time with both in New York City this March.
For tickets, hotel and additional details regarding the 2022 BSM Summit visit BSMSummit.com.
BSM Writers2 days ago
It’s a Golden Era For Bob Fescoe And Kansas City
Sports Radio News3 days ago
Nick Ashooh Exits NBC Sports Washington For Audacy, BetQL
Sports TV News1 day ago
Kate Scott Named New TV Voice of 76ers
Sports Online2 days ago
Andy Holloway Explains How The Fantasy Footballers Became Popular