According to Andrew Marchand of The New York Post, Joe Benigno could return to WFAN by next week, although nothing is definite.
WFAN’s longtime midday show, co-hosted by Benigno and Evan Roberts, remained a staple for the station as the rest of their weekday lineup underwent major changes in the last 12 months, but that changed when Benigno fell victim to controversy on July 19.
After being named in a sexual harassment lawsuit by a former FAN employee, Benigno has been on a leave of absence since late July while the station’s owner, Entercom Communications, works to resolve the case. Entercom did not own WFAN while the alleged sexual harassment took place.
If Benigno was going to be permanently removed from the program, a clean break right after Labor Day would have made the most sense. While the Tuesday after Labor Day is generally when shows reset and hosts stop taking their summer vacations, Marchand notes the more important date is next Thursday when the fall ratings book begins. However, if Benigno does return next week, it does not mean the pending legal matter will be completed.
According to Marchand, some within Entercom believe keeping Benigno off the air would appear as if the company is admitting guilt, although they continue to deny allegations and avoid a settlement. If Joe does return to the show while Entercom still works to handle the lawsuit, a valiant call-screening effort would be needed to keep the program from turning into Benigno repeatedly saying he “can’t talk about legal matters.”
Since Benigno’s absence, Roberts has continued as solo host of the midday show and has had a number of guests sit-in for a full hour, including Barstool’s KFC (Kevin Clancy) on Thursday. Even during his absence, Benigno’s presence remains in the midday as his name was never removed from the show, the Joe and Evan jingle is played daily and Joe’s voice is still heard on Smithtown Nissan commercials. Evan continues to reference Joe on the show to callers and guests, also telling listeners he will offer an update as soon as he receives one.
Last year Benigno signed a three-year contract to remain in WFAN’s midday timeslot, but he made it clear he was retiring and headed to Florida as soon as his current deal is up. Until he returns, an early retirement for the 65 year old Benigno will remain a possibility.
Brandon Contes is a freelance writer for BSM. He can be found on Twitter @BrandonContes. To reach him by email click here.